Is there a limit for former IH hero to qualify here?

There's not a single yes proposal for him. The man deserves to be on this wiki, it’s about time for Ichiban to be the Like a Dragon PG in the franchise

He acts like an arrogant jerk to Bowser.

I mean, besides the fact that it's already in the "Pure Good" category (although it hasn't been officially approved yet), from what I've researched, this version doesn't have that infamous moment of Jesus's rage in the temple or him cursing a fig tree.

Iroh is Ozai's brother.

Soichiro Yagami is Light Yagami's father.

Simba, Kion, and Kiara are Scar's nephew and great-nephew, respectively.

Yuji Itadori is Kenjaku's "son."

Primus is Unicron's brother.

Anna and Elsa are King Runeard's granddaughters.

SCP-999 is the son of the Scarlet King.

Amity Blight is Odalia Blight's daughter.

Mark Evans is Henry Evans' cousin.

Amanda Krueger is Freddy Krueger's mother.

Jack Kline is Chuck (God)'s grandson.

Laurie Strode is Michael Myers' sister.

I know a Pure Evil villain wouldn’t see a Pure Good hero as a genuine friend, but a Pure Good hero might see a Pure Evil villain as a genuine friend. So thus, a Pure Evil villain could be reluctantly friends with a Pure Good hero, name any.

Since the beginning of the story, Shanks has been easygoing, laid-back, but he knew when to get serious when the times called for it. He is the one to inspire Luffy, after all, so it's no wonder why Luffy is the way he is. However, until recently we never learned of his backstory, and I believe we only learned about 8 years ago that he was an Emperor, and that the fruit he was protecting in that treasure chest was not the Gum-Gum fruit, but the Zoan Devil Fruit, the Human-Human Fruit Model Nika, which essentially allowed Luffy to transform into the Sun God Nika as per his Fifth Gear transformation. This put Luffy on the level of an Emperor, and it allowed him and his crew to take on one of the Five Elders.

Anywho, most of Shanks' actions are heroic, such as putting an end to the Marineford War through convincing Sengoku and the Whitebeard Pirates to surrender, saving Koby from Akainu, trying to protect Ace through getting Whitebeard to make sure Ace didn't get into trouble, and defeating Kidd when he attacked the Red Hair Pirates, saving many ships that would have been taken out by Kidd. Though, people do like to point out that this action is somewhat questionable given that he did wipe out his crew via the giants Dorry and Brogy, likely killing them all, though he did give him a chance to stand down. In addition, he ordered the death of Bartolomeo because of his initial burning of the Red Hair Pirates' flag effectively declaring war on them, only stopping when he realized he was Luffy's devoted ally.

Though, another questionable part of Shanks is that, contrary to many people thinking he was secretly a rat for the World Government, it turns out that he was a mole for them, pretending to be on their side as a God's Knight. However, we still don't fully know his motivations for doing so. Another interesting thing about Shanks is that he only decided to go after the One Piece upon hearing of the Straw Hat Grand Fleet in the news and setting Bartolomeo as their next target, instead of deciding to meet Luffy in Wano.

The fact that Shanks even stole the Human-Human Nika Model Devil Fruit has some unknown reasons behind it, and this compounded with his connections to the World Government implies, as many have stated, that he has an overarching plan, so there is a small chance he even end up being something of an extremist when we get more information on him.

Overall, I think while he most likely has good intentions and is definitely a hero, he might end up not being as morally pure as he has appeared so far.

Apologies for the rant, I wanted to address these few ponits. What do you all think? I know it's still too early to tell, but as of now do you think Shanks might get removed from Pure Good eventually?

Out of all the original characters in Fire Emblem Heroes, which ones would you pick for Pure Good? I would definitely pick Askr and Sharena and maybe both Alfonse and Fjorm.

Hi, never proposed on this or Pure Evil yet, probably won't often. I'm thinking of two proposals from the Fraggle Rock franchise for here, but people disagree on the continuity of it. There's the original 80s series, and then Back to the Rock. I'd personally argue BTTR is a full continuity reboot, and my several years old alteration of that from "revival" on TV Tropes hasn't been changed. The original series had a definitive end, and BTTR not only resets the end, but all character development as well. It's a completely new plot. However, I see people get confused about this a lot and debate otherwise because all clarified world building and lore from the original is intact and not explained for modern viewers. Because it's a plot reset and not a world building one, Muppet Wiki has kept all pages unsplit.

Again I'm firmly thinking "different proposals for different continuities", but I'm asking first. This question decides a lot because my planned proposals are:

• Wembley across the whole franchise

• Gobo but ONLY in BTTR, his original counterpart is way too jerky to qualify.

No rush figuring this out, I'm not doing anything until after The First Snow of Fraggle Rock releases this Friday as who knows if that changes anything.

How do the first three stand out, exactly?

I'm assuming this is bc his jerk moment is very minor?

And finally, doesn't he suffer from fridge brilliance though?

I'm just curious

Just another shower-thought question I have for the proposed characters that didn't get the chance they probably deserved on this wiki. I was wondering if you feel any of these characters deserve a chance to carry the title of "pure good". Here they are in alphabetical order.

• Akagi (Kantai Collection)

• Ao Lie (LEGO Monkie Kid)

• Armin Arlert (Attack on Titan)

• Book (Battle for Dream Island)

• Classified (Penguins of Madagascar)

• Cream Puff Cookie (Cookie Run)

• Dick Sand (Dick Sand, A Captain at Fifteen)

• Dug (Up)

• Fa Mulan (Reflection)

• Frank (Graphic MSP)

• Germain St. Germain (Heavy Metal 2000)

• Gilgamech (SteamWorld)

• Glorfindel (The Silmarillion)

• Gracia Hosokawa (Samurai Warriors)

• Hanamaru Kunikida (Love Live! Sunshine)

• Hiroshi Hyuga (Ultraman)

• Homer Parrish (The Best Years of Our Lives)

• Hooty (The Owl House)

• Ike (Fire Emblem)

• Invisible Woman (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

• Latias (Pokémon Heroes/M05)

• Liz Tooms (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

• Nevin (The Ancient Magus’ Bride)

• Nodoka Hanadera (Healin' Good♡Pretty Cure)

• Ocellus (My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic)

• Patamon (Digimon Adventure)

• Princess Isla Kokoro (Barbie: Princess Charm School)

• Raiden (Mortal Kombat, 3rd Timeline)

• Ratso (The Ugly Duckling and Me)

• Robo (Chrono Trigger)

• Rudger (The Imaginary)

• Scarecrow (Oz)

• Solar Flare (Plants vs. Zombies Heroes)

• Spider-Man (Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man)

• Superman (DC Animated Universe)

• The Lake Trio (Pokémon: The Series)

• Toru Umenda (Ultraman Leo)

• Ulala (Space Channel 5)

• William McCall (Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood)

• Yaddle (Star Wars)

Feel free to let me know if I missed anyone

It's generally accepted that the musical isn't cannon to the television series, so he could have his own Moral Scaling.

In terms of his actual character, he saved Bikini Bottom from a volcano and lacks all of his show counterparts corrupting qualities.

What are the most heinous PGs you can think of? Either due to agency issues or fully reformed villains.